
I don’t know what year it was, but it was the year that I got the full Scholastic edition of The Chronicles of Narnia series. If I’m remembering correctly, I got a good number of good books that year. My little stash of gifts probably was very decent.
That was also the first year I can very distinctly remember the sinking feeling in my stomach that descended on me as we began to tidy up the living room of wrapping and boxes and settle in with our new things.
You know the feeling that I’m talking about? It’s the one that feels a lot like disappointment, but you can’t really put your finger on what it was that you really wanted. All you know is that you didn’t get what you really really wanted–you know, the thing that would have certainly made you entirely happy, for at least another 12 months?
That first year, the year of Narnia, was also the year my baby sister got a whole whack load (I’m not even exaggerating!) of Barbies. I was *just* too old to really ask for them, but what I would have given to get a whole box of lovely blonde dolls with outfits and new shoes. Seriously.
As I was thinking about that Christmas this morning, I had a couple of realizations.
First, gifts are central to Christmas. I know that because of the North American practice of giving gifts to practically everyone we know. Our gift giving is almost like our ‘friending’ on Facebook. If you saw their face once or you have one mutual friend, you give them a gift or a card. That leads to the second reason I know gifts are central to Christmas. We spend a whole boatload of money on it. In fact, I’d venture to say that most of the money we spend around Christmas is money spent on those 1001 gifts we have to give. The third reason I know is that when it comes to charity events or campaigns, we are asked to donate presents and toys to the children who won’t get any at Christmas.
There actually is nothing really wrong with most of our gift-giving practices, in and of themselves. …But as I thought about it, I realized that there is quite a bit wrong with our gift-giving motives. In fact, they are actually very perverted.
First? Our gift-giving often can and does incite us to a great amount of sin. What do I mean? Well, think about your own gift-giving. On the most base level, I can be jealous of what other people give because I can’t give “as good” (that is, expensive? gifts like they can. On the most surface level, that thought is envious of others. On a deeper level, it makes us feel a bit guilty if we can’t give as good a gift to someone but they give us a fantastic gift. On an even deeper level, it implies that we give gifts to make others like (or love?) us better. At the deepest level, it makes the gift-giving about the gift-giver, not the gift-getter. Our motive is [almost] entirely based on envy, lies, and selfishness. …That’s a receipe for sin if I’ve ever seen one.
If I manage to not have that thought or motive directing my gift-giving, I have often thought this thought: “Well, if this gift for Dad will cost $25, I’ll have to make sure I buy another $10 gift for Lauren to make it even.” Usually the thought isn’t so plain as that, but I’ve heard its relatives come out of the mouths of other shoppers, so I’m sure I’m not the only one who thinks in this family of thought. Why is this thought sinful? On the surface level, it makes gifts about the monetary cost of them. Why not just give them all cash then? On a deeper level, it takes out the individual thoughtfulness and uniqueness of the receiver of the gifts. Instead of finding a special gift for mom, we’re looking for a good gift that we spent $25 on, same as John’s. On an even deeper level, it makes the gift about the giver, again, and not about the getter. ….Worship of money, concern for man’s approval, and selfishness? Once again, a potent and subtle receipe for sin.
I think the reason they incite us to such levels of sin is because gifts can be so powerful. On the surface, there is something so thrilling about giving a gift that you know the getter is going to totally love and will totally make them feel really special. There is something about opening a box and discovering something in there that is just so thoughtful and great and you didn’t even know you wanted it until you saw there nestled in the wrapping paper.
But on a deeper level, the reason presents are so powerful and so often incite us to sin is because presents are a shadow of the real gift that our hearts are always longing for. And because our hearts long for it, we are so easily swayed to believe that a twisted version of gift-giving will do.
Unlike our gift-giving, God gave freedom and life to us, not because of anything about us, but because of everything He is. He gave because He loved us, yes; but He gave because He wanted to restore His relationship with us–so He would be glorified.
Unlike our gift-giving, God gives freedom and life totally unfairly and totally unequally. We don’t deserve this freedom and life but we get it anyway. …And we know some of our loved ones won’t ever receive it. That’s not fair. And some receive their life just as their fleshy one is giving out while some gain new life mere years into life here on earth. Some struggle with doubt and fear for most of their spiritual and fleshly lives. Some live in complete abandon with a charismatic obsession with Jesus. That’s not equal.
So presents, rightly so, are central to Christmas. We feast and sing and feast and laugh and feast and gift-give and feast and get gifts and feast all because WE were given a GREAT GREAT great gift from our Heavenly Father who knows how to give good and perfect gifts.
When Colleen challenged me to make next year’s Christmas about the Real Gift by not getting any other gifts, I balked a little bit. …I know that left unchecked, my heart would be miserable Christmas 2011. I have some rethinking to do about my gift-giving practices…
What about you?